By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Rohingya Khobor Rohingya Khobor
Notification Show More
Latest News
2023 Joint Response Plan focuses on Rohingya crisis
Rohingya News
Five ARSA members including group commander detained in Ukhiya Rohingya camp
Rohingya News
Rohingya sheltered in Tumbru will be moved elsewhere, UNO
Rohingya News
Mohammed Arman, age 03 missing
Missing Person
Webinar on ‘The Aftermath of the Myanmar February 2021 Coup, and Continued Challenge’
Myanmar
Aa
  • Home
  • Rohingya
    Rohingya
    Show More
    Top News
    Invitation to the Rohingya youths for Human Rights training
    October 24, 2020
    A Rohingya teacher killed and five people injured in Buthidaung
    November 6, 2022
    A poem by a Rohingya refugee: When I was crossing the Naf
    December 13, 2020
    Latest News
    2023 Joint Response Plan focuses on Rohingya crisis
    January 31, 2023
    Five ARSA members including group commander detained in Ukhiya Rohingya camp
    January 31, 2023
    Rohingya sheltered in Tumbru will be moved elsewhere, UNO
    January 31, 2023
    Foreign minister: Rohingya must go back to their motherland
    January 29, 2023
  • World
    WorldShow More
    United States to provide an additional $75 million for the Rohingya and locals
    January 29, 2023
    New criminal case filed against junta in Germany
    January 24, 2023
    Israeli Human Rights group asks to investigate Defense Ministry allegedly helping Myanmar Military
    January 17, 2023
    HRW World Report 2023 reveals Rohingyas sufferings
    January 15, 2023
    Rohingya repatriation is being delayed because of Myanmar: China’s foreign minister
    January 12, 2023
  • Culture
    CultureShow More
    Rohingya Songs and Music
    January 27, 2023
    Traditional Rohingya Houses
    January 15, 2023
    Rohingya Language
    December 26, 2022
    Rohingya/Burmese snack- Bu Thi Kyaw
    December 20, 2022
    An age old traditional Rohingya drink – Faluda
    December 8, 2022
  • Memoriam
    MemoriamShow More
    Rohingya hit by military car and dies
    January 2, 2023
    Injured record
    December 19, 2022
  • Opinion
    OpinionShow More
    First CRC Case filed over violent pushback of Rohingya child
    July 28, 2022
    The Rohingya people face endless detention in Myanmar
    July 4, 2022
    Daily Star ePaper, English News Paper, Today Newspaper, Online News Epaper
    June 14, 2022
    King’s College student organizes a webinar on Myanmar’s present political crisis
    November 2, 2021
    Migration Mobilities Bristol hosting an event on “Citizenship in Myanmar: Past and Future”
    November 2, 2021
  • Missing Person
    Missing PersonShow More
    Mohammed Arman, age 03 missing
    January 31, 2023
    A child was found in Balukhali camp 19 missing
    January 28, 2023
    A child was found in Balukhali camp 20
    January 27, 2023
    Nurul Amin, age 14 missing
    January 25, 2023
    Kobir Ahammed, age 04 missing
    December 5, 2022
  • Library
  • Contact
  • MORE
    • Covid-19
    • Election 2020
    • Coup 2021
    • Repatriation Timeline
  • Audio News
Reading: The Intelligence Dilemma
Share
Aa
Rohingya Khobor Rohingya Khobor
  • Home
  • Rohingya
  • World
  • Culture
  • Memoriam
  • Opinion
  • Missing Person
  • Library
  • Contact
  • MORE
  • Audio News
Search
  • Home
  • Rohingya
  • World
  • Culture
  • Memoriam
  • Opinion
  • Missing Person
  • Library
  • Contact
  • MORE
    • Covid-19
    • Election 2020
    • Coup 2021
    • Repatriation Timeline
  • Audio News
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
Rohingya Khobor > Rohingya Library > Research Report > The Intelligence Dilemma
USA Flag
Research Report

The Intelligence Dilemma

Last updated: 2021/01/02 at 4:59 PM
rohingyakhobor.com Published January 2, 2021
Share
10 Min Read
SHARE

By George Friedman
The United States claims to have identified a massive Russian intelligence operation meant to gather secrets from corporations and the government. The line from Washington is that the operation was successful, but precisely what the Russians gathered has not been disclosed. That the operation was known makes it ineffective from Moscow’s point of view. So the Americans are scrambling to find out how much the Russians saw, and the Russians are scrambling to find out how long U.S. counterintelligence was aware of the operation.

The fact that it was announced recently doesn’t necessarily mean it was only recently detected, and that it was detected doesn’t necessarily mean the United States hasn’t been feeding Russia a trove of misinformation. It is therefore difficult to know who won and who lost. Espionage has always been a complex game, whether carried out by spies on the ground, or by hackers in a comfortable and secure office.

This is a timely reminder that not only do all nations engage in espionage but they are morally obligated to do so. Every government is responsible for national security. It is perhaps its highest obligation. In order to carry out the duty, it must know the capability and intentions of all governments, hostile or friendly. The saying that nations have no permanent friends or permanent enemies but only permanent interests means that leaders must be aware of what other leaders intend. It is essential that they dismiss the statements of the leaders of other nations, since those statements might be utterly sincere or profoundly deceptive. Any government must do all it can to determine the hidden intents and capabilities of others. And since friends can become enemies well before they issue a press release, intelligence is a practice of expecting the worst while hoping for the best.

Moscow’s intelligence operations – now known as hacking – are thus a moral obligation of the Russian state. Moscow must know our intent and capabilities. Policies, the intent of foreign policy, rest in the White House. The capability to act frequently resides in American corporations. This operation by the Russians apparently went after both. The fact that the U.S. has not been caught undertaking an operation of such magnitude doesn’t mean it has not done so. The relative silence about any U.S. operations might be due to the fact that none have been detected. It might be due to the fact that the Russian government is hiding the intrusion in order to maintain domestic credibility. It may be that the Russians detected one and took control of the operations while pretending not to have noticed it.

This much is unknown. What is certain is that the United States is as morally obligated to conduct espionage as the Russians and has prudently operated a vast and capable intelligence organization. The problem is that, as a citizen, I have no idea whether the U.S. intelligence establishment is capable of serving the national interest. I express confidence in that establishment based not on direct knowledge but rather on the assumption that at least some of the money allocated to the intelligence community has been put to good use. Even a fraction of the money spent should be enormously successful. And this is true for all nations, albeit with far more modest budgets.

It is also true that all nations must be allowed to shroud their intelligence operations in secrecy and deception, a “bodyguard of lies” as it was once put. That we do not know how successful Russian hackers were, nor whether the exploit was penetrated months ago, is not the essential problem. All these operations fall in the realm of moral necessity, and I have no need to know. The problem arises from the assumption that the elected leaders of the country may not know how badly compromised the U.S. was by this action, or how badly the Russians were compromised.

Thus is the moral dilemma of intelligence. We need an intelligence service to inform our leaders of the intent of other nations. And in any particular case, we can accept a bodyguard of lies. But U.S. intelligence is vast in terms of personnel and cost. It is also, by profession and law, required to act in secrecy. The entity that is charged with the most important thing this country has cannot readily be judged for competence by elected leaders, let alone by its citizens.

A citizen needs to know that the U.S. is giving as good as it gets, and that China or Russia, each carrying out their duty to their nations, is feeling the righteous anger of the United States. I personally believe we are extremely good, but I don’t know for sure. I can’t know, nor can others, the degree to which our intelligence service is competent, acting within the laws that established it. Its missions are secret, yet that very secrecy forces us to be uncertain about all of these things.

This is not unique to the United States nor to democracies. China has a vast intelligence service, and the Chinese Central Committee has only 200 members or so. They can’t know whether Chinese operatives are stealing technology for the use of the Chinese government, for the use of private Chinese corporations, or to sell to India. In theory, they are undoubtedly monitored, but there is a great deal of money that might be made in ignoring or manipulating them. The process of monitoring any intelligence agency in any country is the ancient Roman question: “Who will guard the guardians?” How can you prevent those monitoring secret operations from succumbing to greed, the most human of vices?

In the United States, we confront this problem in two ways. One is to hold Congressional hearings in which the questioners have no idea what question to ask, nor any real idea whether the answers they get are in any way connected to the truth. The second is to create a new organization to monitor the operating service. Here, there are two choices. One is to appoint someone from outside the intelligence community, which replicates the Congressional dilemma. The other is to appoint an elder statesman from the community, who has invested his life in the service and who may be incapable of impartial and ruthless action.

The most important question is effectiveness. All nations can ignore a measure of corruption if the national interest is served effectively. But how do we know whether the information provided to the president is accurate? In a world that is dangerous to Russia and the United States equally, the necessity of intelligence is obvious, as is the inability of the political leadership to oversee the vast expanse of intelligence operations.

Stalin solved this problem by periodically killing members of his intelligence apparatus. It did not help him, and ultimately hurt him, but it made him feel better. Stalin, far more powerful than Putin, Xi or Trump, couldn’t be certain of his intelligence service. So dubious was he that he ignored their warning of a German invasion. Not trusting the intelligence service can be as calamitous as trusting it.

Intelligence prior to the 20th century was important, but nothing like it is today. It now sprawls in all directions in all nations. The global nature of great power interests generates vast establishments that seem to multiply. We all face the same moral dilemma. We all want to protect our countries. We all reasonably distrust each other. We all build intelligence services generously. They must have a veil of trust, or they can’t work. But in each country, the question is asked: Are they actually competent, and do they tell us the truth? At some point, the solution will not sustain itself.

Dear Reader,
I leave upto you to wonder how the Myanmar government infiltrated into our community and urge you to keep your eyes and ears to be alerted. Our people has lost the most. But it is the high time to rebuild. Let us start with education. Rk wishes all a happy new year.

“Copyright 2020 Geopolitical Futures, LLC. Republished with permission.”

You Might Also Like

Joe Biden’s Defense Adviser is coming to visit the Rohingya camp

Dhaka seeks Russia’s cooperation on Rohingya repatriation

REFLECTING ON THE ANNIVERSARY OF THE ROHINGYA GENOCIDE, MERKLEY, COLLEAGUES CONTINUE PUSH FOR ADDITIONAL SANCTIONS AND INTERNATIONAL INTERVENTION TO RESOLVE HUMANITARIAN CRISIS IN BURMA

FIVE YEARS AFTER START OF ROHINGYA GENOCIDE

TAGGED: Geopolitics, Russia, USA
rohingyakhobor.com January 2, 2021
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print

Facebook

Latest News

2023 Joint Response Plan focuses on Rohingya crisis
Five ARSA members including group commander detained in Ukhiya Rohingya camp
Rohingya sheltered in Tumbru will be moved elsewhere, UNO
Mohammed Arman, age 03 missing
Webinar on ‘The Aftermath of the Myanmar February 2021 Coup, and Continued Challenge’
United States to provide an additional $75 million for the Rohingya and locals

Recent Comments

  • mdzubair on U.S to start Rohingya resettlement from Bangladesh
  • mdzubair on U.S to start Rohingya resettlement from Bangladesh
  • Muhammad irfan on U.S to start Rohingya resettlement from Bangladesh
  • Nurul Amin on U.S to start Rohingya resettlement from Bangladesh
  • sinthiya on A Rohingya teacher killed and five people injured in Buthidaung

FAIR USE NOTICE: This site may contain copyrighted material. Such material is made available for educational purposes, to advance understanding of human rights, democracy, scientific, moral, ethical, and social justice issues, etc. This constitutes a ‘fair use’ of any such copyrighted material as provided for in Title 17 U.S.C. section 107 of the US Copyright Law. This material is distributed without profit.

DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in the articles are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the organisation.

© Rohingya Khobor

Manage Cookie Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?