Seven years after The Gambia went to court, the International Court of Justice found Myanmar responsible for genocide against the Rohingya. The judgment explains how the judges reached that conclusion, which claims they rejected, and what Myanmar owes survivors and displaced families.
By Kawser Hamid | 21 November 2026
- Seven years after The Gambia went to court, the International Court of Justice found Myanmar responsible for genocide against the Rohingya. The judgment explains how the judges reached that conclusion, which claims they rejected, and what Myanmar owes survivors and displaced families.
- From the attacks in northern Rakhine to a case in The Hague
- What the judges accepted as evidence
- Which acts met the Convention’s definition?
- Why the Court found an intent to destroy
- What the Court decided on the other allegations
- The 13 decisions in the judgment
- What Myanmar owes Rohingya survivors and families
- What happens next
For Rohingya families whose villages were destroyed in 2017, the International Court of Justice’s judgment reaches into questions they have lived with for years. Can they return to the places they were driven from? What happens to land now occupied by security installations? Who will help find relatives who disappeared? And what is owed to survivors whose losses cannot be repaired by returning property? On 19 November, the Court held Myanmar responsible for genocide and made each of those questions part of its ruling.
The central finding came by nine votes to six. The judges found that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya in northern Rakhine State during the military’s 2017 “clearance operations”. They separately found that Myanmar failed to prevent genocide by individuals acting alongside its security forces, failed to punish genocide and related acts, failed to enact adequate legislation and breached an earlier order to preserve evidence. The Court settled Myanmar’s responsibility as a state. It kept the case open to determine the amount and arrangements for compensation or other reparation.
From the attacks in northern Rakhine to a case in The Hague
The Court examined earlier waves of displacement and the gradual erosion of Rohingya rights. The 1982 citizenship law and subsequent administrative measures left many Rohingya without secure legal status. Restrictions on movement, marriage and the registration of children affected access to education, health care and livelihoods. The judges considered this history when assessing how the 2017 operations unfolded and why the Rohingya were so vulnerable to them.
Myanmar’s security forces launched operations in northern Rakhine after attacks on security posts in October 2016 and August 2017 by the armed group later known as the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA). Myanmar described its response as counterinsurgency. The 2016 operations drove about 87,000 Rohingya into Bangladesh. More than 700,000 fled after the 2017 operations, joining people displaced in earlier years. In 2018, a UN fact-finding mission reported evidence that warranted investigation and prosecution of senior military officials for genocide.
On 11 November 2019, The Gambia, with backing from the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation, filed a case in its own name under Article IX of the 1948 Genocide Convention. It asked the Court to determine whether Myanmar had breached obligations it owed under the treaty and to order remedies for the Rohingya. The case concerned Myanmar’s responsibility for conduct attributable to the state and for failing to carry out its treaty duties. Criminal liability for individual commanders is a question for courts with criminal jurisdiction.
In its final submissions, The Gambia asked the Court to find Myanmar responsible for genocide during the clearance operations of 2016–2018 in northern Rakhine State. The Court examined evidence from across that period, but its finding that Myanmar committed genocide was confined to the 2017 clearance operations.
| Date | What happened |
|---|---|
| November–December 2019 | The Gambia filed its application and asked for urgent protection while the case was pending. At the December hearings, Aung San Suu Kyi appeared for Myanmar and defended its account of the military operations. |
| 23 January 2020 | The Court unanimously ordered Myanmar to take measures within its power to prevent acts covered by the Convention, ensure that its military and others under its control or influence refrained from prohibited conduct, preserve evidence and report on compliance. The first report was due within four months, with further reports every six months. The order provided interim protection while the allegations were still before the Court. |
| 2020–2022 | The Gambia filed its main written case in October 2020. Myanmar raised four preliminary objections in January 2021. After hearings in February 2022, the Court rejected all four objections on 22 July 2022 and ruled, by 15 votes to one, that it had jurisdiction and that the application was admissible. |
| 2023–2025 | Myanmar filed its written defence within the extended August 2023 deadline. The Gambia replied in May 2024, and Myanmar filed its final written response within the extended December 2024 deadline. The Court dealt with requests to add evidence and with arrangements to protect witnesses while giving each side a chance to respond. |
| 12–29 January 2026 | The judges heard two rounds of oral argument. The Gambia called three witnesses and one expert. Myanmar called one witness. The Court then began deliberations. |
| 19 November 2026 | The Court delivered its judgment on the merits. It ruled on genocide, Myanmar’s other treaty obligations and compliance with the interim order, and set out the next stage on reparations. |
Myanmar’s objections raised four questions. Was the OIC the real applicant? Was there a legal dispute between The Gambia and Myanmar when the case was filed? Did Myanmar’s reservation to Article VIII prevent the case from proceeding? And could The Gambia bring a claim despite having suffered no direct injury? The judges held that The Gambia was the applicant, that a dispute existed and that Myanmar’s reservation to Article VIII did not bar proceedings under Article IX. They also held that every party to the Convention has a legal interest in seeing other parties comply with it. The Gambia could therefore bring the case without showing that it had itself been injured.
Eleven states intervened on how the Convention should be interpreted under Article 63 of the Court’s Statute. They were Belgium, Canada, Denmark, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, France, Germany, Ireland, the Maldives, the Netherlands, Slovenia and the United Kingdom. The Gambia and Myanmar remained the two parties to the dispute.
What the judges accepted as evidence
The Gambia had to prove the facts underlying its allegations. Myanmar was responsible for substantiating facts it asserted in its defence. Given the gravity of a genocide finding, the Court required conclusive evidence for the central allegations. Where intent had to be inferred from a pattern of conduct, the judges asked whether genocidal intent was the only reasonable inference from the evidence taken as a whole. They also took account of unequal access to evidence, including the barriers to investigating inside Myanmar.
The record included testimony from Rohingya survivors, satellite imagery, photographs and videos, official records, statements from former soldiers, and investigations by the UN Fact-Finding Mission and the Independent Investigative Mechanism for Myanmar (IIMM). Myanmar submitted witness statements, official records, military reports and other material. It challenged the weight of the UN findings, arguing in part that investigators had been unable to enter the country. The judges examined how the investigators had gathered, tested and corroborated their evidence. They gave considerable weight to IIMM material and treated the Fact-Finding Mission’s reports as generally reliable, while assessing what each source could establish. The Court also returned sealed versions of statements that had been made available to the Court alone, ruling that it would not rely on evidence withheld from the opposing party.
Which acts met the Convention’s definition?
Under Article II of the Convention, genocide requires both a prohibited act and the specific intent to destroy a protected national, ethnic, racial or religious group, in whole or in part. The Court treated the Rohingya as a protected group and examined four categories of conduct alleged by The Gambia. It found three established.
| Allegation | What the Court found |
|---|---|
| Killing members of the group — Article II(a) | Established. The evidence proved intentional killings of Rohingya. The Court did not need to fix a total death toll or identify every victim to establish this element. |
| Causing serious bodily or mental harm — Article II(b) | Established. The judges found that rape, other sexual violence and attacks on Rohingya civilians inflicted serious physical and psychological harm. They considered the lasting effects on survivors alongside the acts committed during the operations. |
| Inflicting conditions of life calculated to bring about physical destruction — Article II(c) | Not conclusively established. The Court examined displacement, restrictions and deprivation. The evidence fell short of the specific test for this category. The judges still considered evidence of displacement and deprivation when assessing the broader pattern of conduct. |
| Imposing measures intended to prevent births — Article II(d) | Established. The Court assessed restrictions on marriage and births, denial of legal registration for Rohingya children, and widespread rape and other sexual violence. It considered these together, including evidence of lasting harm to survivors’ reproductive health and capacity. |
The fifth category in Article II, forcible transfer of children from one group to another, was outside The Gambia’s claim on the merits.
Why the Court found an intent to destroy
The Gambia produced no direct evidence of a general genocidal plan. It argued that intent could be inferred from attacks in places such as Min Gyi, Chut Pyin and Maung Nu and from the pattern across northern Rakhine. The judges examined the selection of Rohingya targets, the killing of civilians including children, the scale and character of sexual violence, attacks on people trying to flee, and the destruction of Rohingya villages while some neighbouring settlements were left standing. They considered these acts in the context of longstanding discrimination and anti-Rohingya propaganda.
Myanmar argued that the operations were a response to attacks by an armed group. It also submitted that forced expulsion could explain the violence without an intent to destroy. The majority assessed whether either explanation could account for the whole record, including attacks on Rohingya as they fled. It found that counterinsurgency and forcible displacement could coexist with genocidal intent, and concluded that the full pattern could reasonably be explained only by an intent to destroy a substantial part of the Rohingya group. It identified the targeted population as approximately 815,000 Rohingya living in northern Rakhine before the 2017 operations. That figure describes the population the Court found was targeted.
Six judges dissented from the genocide finding. In its 20 November response, Myanmar’s Foreign Ministry pointed to the joint dissent and disputed the majority’s treatment of the evidence and its application of the standard of proof. The majority judgment remains binding on the parties.
What the Court decided on the other allegations
Failure to prevent genocide. The judges found that Myanmar knew or should have known of a serious risk that civilians acting alongside its forces would commit genocide. It had the means to act and failed to use them. This finding addressed Myanmar’s duty to prevent acts by those individuals, alongside its responsibility for genocide committed by its own security forces.
Direct and public incitement. The judges considered anti-Rohingya propaganda as part of the evidence on intent. For the separate allegation that Myanmar directly and publicly incited private individuals to commit genocide, the Convention required proof of a direct appeal to commit genocidal acts. The Court found that the evidence did not meet that test. It treated alleged incitement of Myanmar’s own forces as absorbed by the finding that the state itself committed genocide.
Failure to punish. The Court examined Myanmar’s domestic inquiries and military trials. At Inn Din, for example, four officers and three soldiers were sentenced to ten years for killing ten people whom Myanmar described as alleged ARSA members. All seven were pardoned after serving eight months. The Court found that the limited domestic proceedings fell short of the duty to investigate and, where warranted, prosecute and punish offences under the Convention.
The Gambia asked the Court to order Myanmar to bring suspects before an independent and effective tribunal, including an international criminal tribunal. The Court instead ordered Myanmar to take immediate and effective steps to investigate anyone reasonably suspected of offences under the Convention in connection with the 2017 operations, and to prosecute and punish them where warranted. The judgment did not designate a tribunal for those cases.
Failure to enact adequate laws. Before 2021, Myanmar’s domestic law had no specific genocide offence. Its 2021 amendments still left gaps. They allowed measures intended to prevent births to fall outside the offence if permitted by existing domestic laws and failed to give full effect to the Convention’s provisions on related offences such as conspiracy and direct and public incitement.
Breach of the interim order. The Court found that Myanmar violated its duty to preserve evidence. It cited the destruction in May 2020 of the remnants of at least five Rohingya villages in Buthidaung and the completion in 2021 of at least one government base on former Rohingya village sites in Maungdaw. The judges found no breach of the first two interim measures on the evidence before them. Myanmar submitted all 13 required interim reports, and that six-monthly reporting requirement ended with the November judgment. The Court ordered a separate report for the reparations phase.
The Gambia also sought reparation for harm caused by breaches of the interim order, to the extent that the other remedies did not already cover it. For the breach it found, the Court held that formally declaring Myanmar in violation of its duty to preserve evidence was sufficient. It considered that the existing order to investigate and, where warranted, prosecute and punish also applied in this context. It therefore awarded no separate remedy for the evidence-preservation breach.
The 13 decisions in the judgment
The final paragraph, paragraph 646, is the part of the judgment that formally records the Court’s findings and orders.
| No. | Finding or order | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya in northern Rakhine during the 2017 operations. | 9–6 |
| 2 | Myanmar failed to prevent genocide by individuals acting alongside its security forces. | 9–6 |
| 3 | The allegation that Myanmar directly and publicly incited private persons to commit genocide was rejected. | 14–1 |
| 4 | Myanmar breached its duty to punish genocide and related acts under Article III. | 11–4 |
| 5 | Myanmar breached its duty to enact legislation giving effect to the Convention. | 14–1 |
| 6 | Myanmar must enact legislation that gives full effect to the Convention. | 14–1 |
| 7 | Myanmar must promptly and effectively investigate anyone reasonably suspected of Convention offences connected to the 2017 operations and prosecute and punish where warranted. | 13–2 |
| 8 | Myanmar must provide guarantees against repetition and prevent similar violations. | 9–6 |
| 9 | Myanmar must carry out the restitution measures set out in paragraph 615. | 10–5 |
| 10 | Myanmar must compensate the Rohingya group and its members for harm that restitution cannot repair. | 10–5 |
| 11 | The Court will determine the amount and arrangements for compensation or other reparation in a later phase. Myanmar must report within two years. | 10–5 |
| 12 | Myanmar breached the interim order to protect and preserve evidence. | 11–4 |
| 13 | The Court rejected the remainder of The Gambia’s submissions. | Unanimous |
What Myanmar owes Rohingya survivors and families
The restitution order covers Rohingya displaced inside Myanmar as well as abroad as a result of Myanmar’s wrongful acts. Paragraph 615 requires Myanmar to take five measures.
- Allow and facilitate safe, voluntary and dignified return to people’s places of residence and help reunite separated families.
- Return or replace lost or damaged property, including property held collectively by Rohingya communities.
- Help search for the disappeared and recover, identify and rebury those killed, with dignity and in accordance with Rohingya traditions.
- Provide physical and psychological rehabilitation to those injured.
- Protect the Rohingya from discrimination and persecution.
Citizenship was a specific point of dispute. The Gambia asked the Court to order full and equal citizenship for every Rohingya. The judges declined to make that blanket order. They explicitly held that protection from discrimination includes access to citizenship and freedom of movement. They also addressed The Gambia’s requests concerning Rohingya self-identification and livelihoods, saying that these were covered by the measures ordered insofar as they address the harms and help prevent repetition.
Myanmar also argued that The Gambia lacked standing to seek reparations for Rohingya victims. The Court held that The Gambia’s legal interest in enforcing the Convention allowed it to seek restitution and compensation for the direct benefit of the Rohingya group and its members. The amount of compensation, the arrangements for distributing it and any other appropriate reparation remain for the next phase.
What happens next
Myanmar has until 19 November 2028 to tell the Court what restitution measures it has adopted and, where full restitution is materially impossible, set out the amount and arrangements it proposes for compensation. That date is the deadline for Myanmar’s report. The Court will then hear the parties’ views and decide how to proceed on reparations. The findings already settled in the November judgment cannot be reopened in that phase.
The two-year deadline applies to Myanmar’s report on restitution and compensation. The Court identified Myanmar’s failure to enact adequate legislation and its failure to investigate, prosecute and punish offences under the Convention as continuing breaches. Myanmar must enact legislation that gives full effect to the Convention and take immediate, effective steps to investigate reasonably suspected offences linked to the 2017 operations. Those duties apply while the reparations phase is pending.
The judgment is binding. If Myanmar fails to comply, The Gambia can take the matter to the UN Security Council under Article 94 of the UN Charter. The Council has discretion over whether to recommend or decide on measures to give effect to the judgment. The Court’s ruling itself imposes no sanctions.
For a Rohingya family in Cox’s Bazar, implementation will be measured in concrete terms. It will mean being able to choose whether to return, finding out what happened to missing relatives, recovering land or obtaining a remedy for its loss, and being able to live and move without persecution. The judgment puts those obligations on Myanmar. The next phase will determine how losses that cannot be repaired through restitution are to be compensated.
Kawser Hamid is a former journalist.


